Identify the logical flaw in the following argument: 'If we invest in renewable

Practice Questions

Q1
Identify the logical flaw in the following argument: 'If we invest in renewable energy, we will eliminate all pollution.'
  1. It assumes a direct cause-effect relationship.
  2. It overlooks economic implications.
  3. It ignores technological limitations.
  4. It is based on outdated information.

Questions & Step-by-Step Solutions

Identify the logical flaw in the following argument: 'If we invest in renewable energy, we will eliminate all pollution.'
  • Step 1: Read the argument carefully: 'If we invest in renewable energy, we will eliminate all pollution.'
  • Step 2: Identify the main claim: The claim is that investing in renewable energy will completely eliminate pollution.
  • Step 3: Look for assumptions: The argument assumes that renewable energy alone can solve all pollution problems.
  • Step 4: Consider other factors: Pollution can come from many sources, not just energy production, such as transportation, industry, and waste.
  • Step 5: Recognize the flaw: The argument oversimplifies the issue by suggesting that one solution (renewable energy) will fix everything (all pollution).
  • Causal Oversimplification – The argument incorrectly assumes that one action (investing in renewable energy) will completely resolve a complex issue (all pollution).
Soulshift Feedback ×

On a scale of 0–10, how likely are you to recommend The Soulshift Academy?

Not likely Very likely